wizard

February 22, 2006

The Stanford Daily Blog Swarm


Bees! I've participated in and watched from the sidelines plenty of "blog swarms" in my time.

Bloggers on the political side of the blogosphere constantly swarm around issues important and trivial. On the business side, bloggers can get pretty nasty with the flaming, if you can believe it (Business blogging seems so benign, doesn't it?).

There's one currently brewing in, for lack of a better word, the literary side of the blogosphere. Some college kid writing for The Stanford Daily Online tried to be clever with a malicious, un-funny bit of satire titled, A guide to effective terrorism?, written by Christopher Lin, who must be regretting his decision to write it by now.

The site will probably be slow-loading because Melissa Anelli at The Leaky Cauldron (impressive stats) got wind of it, wrote an excellent response, and linked. Here's an excerpt of Child Christopher's piece:

Just when international tension is running at fever pitch, the terrorists should move in with their piece de resistance — kidnap J.K. Rowling and hold her hostage. It’s the perfect climax for this unfortunate series of events. The world has gradually nursed a cancerous addiction to Harry Potter over the last decade, and tension is running high as the entire world awaits the seventh chronicle with bated breath. When the terrorists release footage of Rowling gagged and tied to a chair, surrounded by vaguely Middle Eastern-looking men carrying large firearms, blood will run in the streets as Potter fans accidentally stab each other while waving plastic wands in an attempt to curse the terrorists to death. Meanwhile, soldiers at the front, terrified that they’ll die before Ron gets a chance to pork Hermione, will lay down their arms, and fighting will come to a standstill until Rowling is safely recovered. Angry citizens throughout the United States and the United Kingdom will rally at their capitals, demanding concessions to all terrorist demands.

Pretty offensive stuff (the part about JKR, not Middle Eastern-looking men). Here's an excerpt of Melissa's response (wait for the jump):

It is highly inflammatory, vivid and at times grotesque, and purports to give ideas to terrorists who wish to run effective terror campaigns. Press being (thankfully) free, it does of course have every right to exist and be published - but that precious, sacred right does not exempt anyone from responsibility for what they pen.

I was a college journalist, and so I know where Mr. Lin is coming from; it's an exciting thing, to get your first taste of free speech, to test the boundaries with your audience, to be inflammatory because you can be, and not because it contributes something intelligent and worthwhile to the national debate. In our college newsroom we were as arrogant as any other college newsroom - we were right, the world was wrong, and why could no one see that? That time is important - it's an exhilarating and crucial pressure cooker, during which many journalists develop their tone and sense of responsibility.

You don't like Harry Potter? Fine, that's your right, and your right to say. You think a Harry Potter love is something to be called cancerous? Fine, that's your right, and your right to say. No one is asking everyone in the world to understand why this series has such an avid following - no one is making apologies for loving it, either. But to use such a love, such an example of fun and goodness in literature, a worldwide community who are rarely anything but understanding and loving, and the figure who means the most to them, as a reason to will violence, is horrendous.

Are HP fans too sensitive? Perhaps. To understand the weight of it all, read Melissa's entire post.

With a high-profile and beloved site like Leaky blogging about the article, I predict the mainstream media will get in on the action by tomorrow morning.


by @ 6:31 pm Filed under J.K. Rowling




5 Responses to “The Stanford Daily Blog Swarm”

  1. Bill Peschel Says:

    This is not a completely considered response, but I hope Melissa never hears of a fellow named Jonathan Swift. Reading him will set her hair on fire.

  2. Jared Says:

    Maybe Melissa has overracted a bit - I don't know, I've yet to read the rest of her response - but I wouldn't go so far as to compare Christopher Lin to Jonathan Swift. Swift is considered and clever; Lin is…not.

    Really, I don't have a problem hyperbole and satire. Say what you like. As long as you say it well.

    '…bombed the living s*** out of Mickey Mouse…' is a far cry from '…a young healthy child well nursed is at a year old a most delicious, nourishing, and wholesome food…'.

    And, again, Swift has a point; Lin doesn't.

  3. Pauli Says:

    Oh, yes, how many times have we heard Swift's name brought up in defense of something inflammatory. Swift was describing conditions in Ireland by means of a hyperbole. (And Jared's right - he was much more clever than this goofball.) Lin is not shedding light on anything here, just trying to enrage Potter fans via an unfair caricature. Even the nuttiest among us who love to dissect the series and come up with wild speculations aren't living to see characters get "porked", barring a miniscule disturbed few. He obviously trying to provoke an angry reaction. The reality of terrorism and beheadings is a mere convenience for his clumsy attention-getting scheme.

  4. janet Says:

    Eager as Mr. Lin seems to be for his own fame, he seems to have given no thought whatsoever as to what "fame" can mean. Perhaps it's time for him to wrest his mind away from his own cleverness and think about things from (shock!) someone else's point of view.

    Ms. Rowling, unlike a movie star or rock star, didn't ask to be famous. As one of the wealthiest people on the planet, she undoubtedly lives her life surrounded by security, as unobtrusive as she can make it, I'm sure. Millions of people know her name, millions of people know her face, millions of people want just five minutes with her…

    And a few of those millions want more. Some are true fanatics, some are mentally unhinged, some are likely out-and-out dangerous.

    And, thanks to Mr. Lin, now possibly some are terrorists, sitting back to contemplate this new venue for their life's work. Because, you know, from a terrorist's point of view, Lin's idea isn't a bad idea at all, and could indeed be quite… effective.

    Tom Hanks was once asked if he was worth $20 million a movie. He replied (very rough paraphrase) that the $20 million wasn't for making the movie at all — he would do that for free. No, the $20 million covers the fact that he can't go to a movie with his kids, he can't go to McDonald's, he can't go to the supermarket, he can't go anywhere in public, really… and he has to live behind bars, as it were.

    In his own desire for fame, Lin is trafficking in the irresponsible and possibly dangerous. Perhaps the most just consequence would be for him to get the fame he drools for… and see how quickly his snarky little tune would change.

  5. LMB Says:

    Thanks so much for commenting, Janet. Lin is young and will learn. As Melissa said, he's feeling the power of a free press and must learn how to use it responsibly.

    By the way, I LOVE your set-ups/pay-offs posts. :)

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

Site Navigation:



Subscribe to FFC


feed
Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz

Recent Comments:

Previous 10 Posts:

Categories:

Recent Trackbacks:

Search blog:

Archives:

February 2006
M T W T F S S
« Jan   Mar »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  
Harry Potter trio

HP Fan Conferences

Phoenix Rising
Sectus
Prophecy

Articles:

Harry Potter News:

41 minutes ago
9 hours ago
9 hours ago
9 hours ago
9 hours ago
10 hours ago
14 hours ago
Succoured by feed dot informer dot com

Narnia News:

1 hour ago
2 hours ago
11 hours ago
14 hours ago
22 hours ago
2 days ago
2 days ago
Provided by FeedInformer

Blogs:

Christian Resources:

Literary & Other Resources:


Notices: