wizard

April 20, 2007

Plot Hole: 'You must not be seen.'


time turnerWe know that bad things have happened to wizards who traveled through time. Some have ended up killing their past or future selves, we were told.

How many times did Hermione say that she and Harry "couldn't be seen" by anyone when they traveled to the past to save Sirus and Buckbeak in Prisoner of Azkaban? Before she and Harry traveled back, Dumbledore reiterated the point: "You know the rules, Ms. Granger. You must not be seen."

It hadn't occurred to me until I listened to the audio book for the nth time that Hermione not only did the very thing people traveling through time are warned against, she did so with the Ministry of Magic's blessing! Hermione appealed to Professor McGonagall for a Time Turner so she could increase her course load, and McGonagall managed to convince the Ministry that Hermione would use it responsibly. So with the TT, she'd attend a 9 a.m. class, and then travel back in time to attend another 9 a.m. class.

Hermione was seen. Didn't that violate some kind of rule? Obviously, the Ministry and McGonagall (and Dumbledore) thought it was OK. If that's the case, why the repeated warnings when rescuing Sirius and Buckbeak? Was it because there were two of them?

Color me confused. Perhaps I missed something in the book.


by @ 3:15 pm Filed under Harry Potter
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

Site Navigation:



Subscribe to FFC


feed
Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz

Recent Comments:

Previous 10 Posts:

Categories:

Recent Trackbacks:

Search blog:

Archives:

April 2007
M T W T F S S
« Jan   May »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
Harry Potter trio

HP Fan Conferences

Phoenix Rising
Sectus
Prophecy

Articles:

Harry Potter News:

11 minutes ago
13 minutes ago
2 hours ago
6 hours ago
8 hours ago
9 hours ago
10 hours ago
In Association with FeedInformer

Narnia News:

45 minutes ago
2 hours ago
3 hours ago
5 hours ago
8 hours ago
8 hours ago
1 day ago
Brought to you by Feed Informer

Blogs:

Christian Resources:

Literary & Other Resources:


Notices: