
SPOILERS BELOW!
Chapter 31-Epilogue
In Chapter 31, Voldemort makes an announcement to the school, loud-speaker style: “Give me Harry Potter, and none shall be harmed. Give me Harry Potter, and I shall leave the school untouched. Give me Harry Potter, and you will be rewarded.”
Slytherin Pansy Parkinson makes to seize Harry, now in the Great Hall, and the students point their wands at her. Still looking for Ron and Hermione, Harry sees Muggle-born Colin Creevey, who snuck into the school to fight. Harry sets out to look for the diadem Horcrux. Since Flitwick told him no one as seen it “in living memory,” Harry realizes a ghost might know what happened to it. He asks Nearly Headless Nick about the diadem, who tells him to ask the Grey Lady, Ravenclaw’s ghost.
The Grey Lady was Rowena Ravenclaw’s kid, and she’d stolen the diadem. Dying, Rowena sent the (Bloody) Baron to find her daughter, whom he loved. She refused to return with him, so he killed her, then himself. That’s how he became the Bloody Baron, Slytherin’s ghost. The Grey Lady hid the diadem inside a hollow of a tree in a forest in Albania. This answers a fandom question, “In Book 1, why was Voldemort hiding out in Albania?” The Grey Lady told a young Tom Riddle about the diadem. He found it and hid it in Hogwarts. After he tried to kill Harry, his half-self went back to the secluded forest to hide.
But where was the diadem now? In the hiding place version of the Room of Requirement. In Book 6, Harry hid his potions book in a room filled with dangerous and banned objects. He marked the spot by putting a wig and the diadem on a nearby bust.
Ron Speaks Parseltongue?
Deathly Hallows, like all of JKR’s books, is rich in detail. Asking and answering questions, making observations, and commenting on everything that made me stop and go, “Hmmm,” would fill up enough books to make a seven-part series of my own. Consequently, I’ve skipped over a lot of things I wanted to explore more fully, but I have to pause for this Ron-speaking-Parseltongue thing.
Starting with Book 2, it’s been drilled into our heads how rare this talking-to-snakes “gift” is. Harry can do it because some of Voldemort’s powers were transferred into Harry when he tried to kill him. We learn in Chapter 31 that Ron spoke Parseltongue to get into the Chamber to get the fangs. How? Did he fake it? If so, how was did his fakery fool the Chamber?
Three More Dead and Panic Attacks
Moving on…Ron tells Harry that Hermione destroyed the Hufflepuff Horcrux with one of the fangs. The trio enters the Room of Requirement (now the Room of Hidden Things) to find the diadem, and Harry’s ambushed by Draco, Crabbe, and Goyle. Spells start flying, and so does the diadem. Crabbe tries to kill Hermione and Ron with the Avada Kedavra curse, misses, and conjures a cursed fire that chases the trio.
Harry, Ron, and Hermione grab brooms to escape and double back to try to save Malfoy, Crabbe, and Goyle. All escape the flames except Crabbe, who’s killed. The fire destroys the diadem Horcrux. In the corridor, the Death Eaters attack. Fred is killed.
The diadem is destroyed, now it’s time to kill Nagini, the snake that contains part of Voldemort’s soul. Harry sees Voldemort and Lucius in the Shrieking Shake. He sends Lucius to fetch Snape. The trio head to the Shack.
I have to pause here to highlight a nice parallel JKR set up. In Book 1, Hermione panics when Harry and Ron are about to be suffocated by the Devil’s Snare on the way to the Sorcerer's Stone. She remembers that it doesn’t like fire. Ron tells her to make the fire, and she yells, “But there’s no wood!” In irritation, Ron says something like, “There’s no wood? Are you a witch, or not?”
In Deathly Hallows, they’re about to enter the Shrieking Shack but must get past the Whomping Willow. Ron says, “How’re we going to get in? I can—see the place—if we just had—Crookshanks again—”
In Book 3, Crookshanks the cat pressed a knob at the base of the tree to stop the branches from moving. Now it’s Hermione’s turn. “Crookshanks? Are you a wizard, or what?” Cool.
So the trio goes through the tunnel to the Shack and sees Voldemort and Snape, who keeps insisting that he must find Harry Potter for him. Voldemort believes Snape is the true owner of the Elder Wand, since he killed Dumbledore, the last holder. In a most inglorious and un-heroic scene, Voldemort sics Nagini on Snape, killing him with a bite to the neck.
And that’s it. The most intriguing character in the series, the double agent who risked his life spying for Dumbledore, who loved Harry’s mother, and who promised Dumbledore he’d protect Lily’s child, is snuffed out. I was hoping Snape would get his moment of glory, reveal his treachery, and stand physically between Voldemort and Harry in a duel, fighting alongside him. Can you picture it? Snake face, Snape, and Harry, dueling at Hogwarts. Alas, it was not to be. Snape drops like a sack of potatoes on the dirty Shack floor.
Harry enters the room, taking off his cloak. Snape gives Harry his memories, which he collects in a flask Hermione conjured. Before he dies, he whispers to Harry, “Look…at…me.”
This is one reason why Harry’s green eyes, so much like his mother’s, are mentioned throughout the series. Snape left the dark side to work for the good because he loved Lily and felt responsible for her death. He wanted to look into "her" green eyes one last time. A poignant scene but the Harry Potter slash fiction folks will have a field day with it.
Now here’s another convenient but unrealistic plot device: Voldemort makes another announcement, giving Harry one hour to turn himself in. OK. One of the world’s greatest sorcerers is giving his nemesis an hour to come up with a way to beat him? Real smooth. Why not give him five minutes or no minutes? An hour? Alas, Harry needs that hour to see Snape’s memories. How considerate of the Dark Lord!
Inside the headmaster’s office, Harry pours Snape’s memories into the Pensieve. We learn that Snape knew Lily as child. He was “that awful boy” Petunia mentioned in Book 5, the same boy many in fandom (including me) suspected she was referring to.
Captivated by Lily even as a child, Snape watched her perform magic while playing with her sister. The boy Snape told her what they were. He told her about Hogwarts and the letters they’d receive. They form a friendship. Lily knows about the arguments between Snape’s parents and how his Muggle father doesn’t like magic. Petunia, hiding behind a tree, is discovered when she loses her footing. After she insults him, Snape causes a tree branch to fall on her, and Lily runs after her, furious at Snape.
The scene changes, and we see Lily and her family and Snape and his on Platform 9 ¾ ready to board the Hogwarts Express. It’s revealed that Petunia, a Muggle, wrote to Dumbledore, asking to attend the wizarding school. So Petunia didn’t always hate magic. Probably already jealous of her more attractive younger sister, Petunia’s bitterness solidified when they were still children.
Lily and Snape encounter the future Marauders on the train. Snape, James, and Sirius exchanged the first of what will become many insults. The scene shifts again, and the first years are being sorted. Lily, in Gryffindor, watches her friend walking to the Slytherin table.
In a different scene, Lily is concerned about Snape’s fascination with the Dark Arts. He shrugs it off and questions her about James, who he knows fancies her. Oh, the Green-Eyed Monster will get you if you don’t watch out!
Snape’s Worst Memory
Many fans have wondered why the scene in which James and Sirius hex Snape is his worst memory. After Harry saw this memory in Book 6, an enraged Snape throws him out of his office. Was he merely embarrassed? Perhaps, but it goes much deeper. Wandless, Snape was unable to defend himself against James and Sirius. In his anger, he calls his best friend, the girl he’s in love with, a Mudblood. This ends the friendship. Later, he apologies, but Lily’s “not interested.”
Double Agent
In the next scene, Snape 's on a hilltop, waiting for Dumbledore. He confesses that he told Voldemort about Trewlaney’s prophecy about a child born at the end of July with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord. Voldemort believes Lily will have that child. Snape pleads with Dumbledore to keep Lily — and her husband and child — safe. In return, Snape offers his services to the good side.
The scene changes again. Lily and James are dead. Voldemort found them. An anguished Snape, wanting to make amends for what he’d done, promises to protect her son. He makes Dumbledore promise never to tell Harry.
“My word, Severus, that I shall never reveal the best of you? If you insist…”
The scene shifts from Harry’s first year, where Snape complains to Dumbledore that Harry is arrogant like his father, to the fourth year, where Snape says his Dark Mark is becoming darker. Voldemort is getting stronger. In the next scene, we see Snape working spells over an injured Dumbledore. In Book 6, the headmaster had found the ring Horcrux, which contained the Resurrection Stone. In his desire to see his dead family, he tried on the ring. The curse “killed” him, but Snape stoppered his death, delaying it for about a year.
Scar Horcrux
Knowing he’s going to die in a year anyway, Dumbledore tells Snape he must kill him when the time is right. In the next scene, Dumbledore tells Snape why he’s teaching Harry — and Harry alone — about what he needs to do to defeat Voldemort.
The night Voldemort tried to kill Lily, his killing curse rebounded. Here’s the kicker: Harry’s scar contains part of Voldemort’s soul, which explains the connection between the two wizards. “[W]hile that fragment of soul, unmissed by Voldemort, remains attached to and protected by Harry, Lord Voldemort cannot die,” Dumbledore tells Snape.
The realization hits Snape: Harry must die. Snape reacts in anger, accusing Dumbledore of raising Harry like a pig for slaughter. He’s been protecting the boy all this time, only to see Dumbledore send him to his death? But it’s not Harry Snape cares about. To clear up the headmaster’s confusion about why he’s angry, Snape conjures a sliver doe Patronus, the same as Lily’s, the same Patronus that beckoned Harry in the woods and led him to the Sword of Gryffindor earlier in the book.
Still Under Orders
In the next scene, Snape the spy is ensconced as headmaster and Voldmort has captured the castle. Dumbledore is dead, but Snape receives orders from Dumbledore’s portrait. He agrees to feed the Order’s escape plans for Harry to Voldemort. Harry sees Snape attempting to curse another Death Eater, but the curse missed and hit took off George's ear. Harry also sees Snape crying in Grimmauld Place over Lily’s letter to Sirius. He’s the one who took the second page of the letter and Lily’s part of the photo.
The next memory reveals that Snape communicated with Phineas Nigellus’s portrait. Phineas calls Hermione a Mudblood. Remembering how much the slur cost him, he tells Phineas not to use the word. Snape plans to send his Patronus to lead Harry to the sword. The memories end.
Death and Resurrection
JKR has called “The Forest Again” her favorite chapter in the book. Harry realizes that he has to allow Voldemort to kill him in order to destroy the part of Voldemort’s soul that’s inside him.
Imagine knowing when and how you’re going to die. Suddenly, you’re aware of your heart beating and your lungs expanding. You’re aware of yourself in a way you’ve never been before. You can count the remaining minutes of your life as time ticks away.
Harry’s doing some quick soul-searching at the beginning of this chapter. He’d always assumed Dumbledore wanted him to survive the final battle with Voldmort. Now, he faced something very different. This is why he told only Harry about the Horcruxes and asked him to tell no one but Ron and Hermione.
Willing to face death, Harry dons the cloak and goes to find Voldemort. On the way, he tells Neville that the snake Nagini, which holds part of Voldemort’s soul, must be killed. Walking toward the forest, where Voldemort has gathered his cronies, Harry pulls the Snitch Dumbledore willed to him out of his pouch. I open at the close. He suddenly understands what it means: the Snitch, which contains the Resurrection Stone, will open at the close of his life.
“I am about to die,” Harry says, and the Snitch opens. With the Stone, he summons his dead loved ones, who’re neither flesh nor ghosts. His mother, father, godfather Sirius, and Lupin, who was killed in the battle earlier than night, walk with him deeper into the forest.
When I read that Harry Potter had to die to destroy Voldemort, I was horrified he'd found out in such a detached way. No one was there to explain, to comfort. But when his loved ones showed up to walk beside him, it was as though his calmness radiated out of the book, and my fear for this fictional character’s life abated.
Two Death Eaters emerge from behind a tree. Unable to see Harry under the cloak, they lead him to the clearing where Voldemort and his Death Eaters are waiting. His family vanishes, and Harry steps forward. Hagrid, bound to a tree, yells, “HARRY! NO!”
But it’s time. With no wand in his hand, Harry’s ready to die. Voldemort sends the killing curse, and it’s lights out for Harry.
“King’s Cross” is a strange chapter. Harry wakes up in a sort of netherworld, naked. He wishes for clothes, and they appear on his body. He’s sees a baby-like figure in a corner, whimpering. Some readers say it symbolizes the part of Voldemort’s soul that died when he killed Harry.
Harry sees Dumbledore and asks, “Then…I’m dead, too?”
“Ah. That is the question, isn’t it? On the whole, dear boy, I think not.”
And we learn why Dumbledore had that gleam in his eye when Voldemort took Harry’s blood in Book 4 and what the prophecy really meant. Voldemort has Harry’s blood inside him, and as long as he lives, Harry survives. With Harry’s blood inside him, Lily’s sacrifice to save Harry lives on. Voldemort didn’t take the time to understand this kind of “deeper magic,” similar to the White Witch’s ignorance in C.S. Lewis’s The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
Dumbledore and Harry are in a place that looks like King’s Cross station. King’s Cross? The cross of Christ? JKR ditched the subtlety for Book 7, didn’t she?
Dumbledore explains his temptation with the Deathly Hallows and his hunt for them. Possessing all three — the Cloak, the Stone, and the Elder Wand — makes the holder the “master of Death.” Dumbledore explains why he had James’s cloak the night James died. He wanted to examine one of the Deathly Hallows, passed down to James through his ancestors.
Dumbledore tells Harry that by having Snape kill him, he intended for Snape to be the Elder Wand’s new owner. But Voldemort got to it first.
Harry chooses to return to life.
I confess myself disappointed with this chapter. There was too much exposition. Mostly all of Harry’s questions were answered, and the revelations came too quickly. But if I had my way, Deathly Hallows would be twice as long.
Ding, Dong, The Wizard's Dead
In the next to last chapter, the final battle begins. Again, too quick. Harry wakes up still on the ground. Voldemort sends Narcissa Malfoy over to see if Harry’s really dead. She feels his beating heart and asks if her son is still alive. Harry tells her yes. Concerned only for her son and wanting to get into the castle, she lies to Voldemort. “He is dead!” Voldemort performs the Cruciatus Curse on Harry’s body, yet the very-much-alive Harry feels no pain. Didn’t understand that part.
The group goes up to the castle, and Hagrid’s crying with the “dead” Harry in his arms. Still feigning death, Harry hears people cry out as Voldemort tells them he’s dead. Neville confronts Voldemort, who summons the Sorting Hat, places it on Neville’s head, and sets in on fire, which prompts Harry to act.
Neville cuts off Nagini’s head, chaos ensues, and everyone is fighting, wizards and magical creatures alike. The matronly Mrs. Weasley ends up killing Bellatrix (sorry Neville!), and Harry protects her as Voldemort tries to curse her.
Harry’s alive, and the showdown begins. This wouldn’t happen in real life, but instead of just killing (or trying to) Harry, Voldemort chills out and listens to him explain why he’s still alive. He tells him that Snape was double agent, that Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him, and that Voldemort, contrary to his belief, did not possess the Elder Wand. Draco, who disarmed Dumbledore, became the true owner, and Harry, who took it from Draco, was now the true owner.
Harry is the true master of the Elder Wand. Unremorseful about everything he’d done, Voldemort threw the killing curse at Harry, who shouted his trademark Expelliarmus spell at the same time. The two spells meet, and the Elder Wand flies out of Voldemort’s hand into Harry’s. Voldmort drops. His killing curse rebounded on him. Again!
Harry, who doesn’t want to be the master of Death, dropped the Resurrection Stone in the forest and plans to put the Elder Wand back in Dumbledore’s tomb. All is well.
The events in the Epilogue occur 19 years later. The married Harry and Ginny are dropping off their sons James and Albus Severus at King’s Cross station to catch the Hogwarts Express. Daughter Lily will head to the school in two years. The married Ron and Hermione are seeing off their daughter Rosie. Son Hugo is too young. Harry’s godson, Teddy Lupin, orphaned son of Lupin and Tonks, has completed his wizarding education. He’s on the platform kissing his Hogwarts-student girlfriend, Bill’s and Fleur’s daughter Victoire, goodbye.
And it’s goodbye to the cast and crew of the Harry Potter series. But the canon is not complete. JKR answered fans’ questions last week, providing character and plot details that weren’t in the book. She’ll also write an encyclopedia, with detailed information about characters. I’m looking forward to it.
If anyone is still with me, thanks for sloughing through this very long post. I wrote this three part summary for myself so I can reference details quickly in future posts. If you get something out of it, too, I’m glad.
Addendum: Corrections are noted and appreciated.


Maintained by La Shawn Barber, this site is not affiliated with Time Warner Entertainment Company, LP, Warner Brothers, The Walt Disney Company, Walden Media, Scholastic, Inc., or Bloomsbury Books. Copyrights and trademarks for books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners. Their use is allowed under Fair Use.
Unless otherwise noted, site design modifications, original writing, and photography are copyrighted by LBC Media, All Rights Reserved.
Original WP theme Copyright Mike Little
August 8th, 2007 at 2:40 am
I remember wondering why the Cruciatus curse didn't cause Harry pain in the forest.
I think the reason was explained by Harry in his info-dump to Voldemort right at the end. He told Voldemort that since the Elder Wand didn't belong to him, it wasn't working right (or something like that).
August 8th, 2007 at 10:11 am
About Voldemort giving Harry one hour to turn himself over: I think Voldemort did that to further terrorize the Resistance inside Hogwarts. Voldemort knows that where there's one Pansy Parkinson, there's probably more if you apply more pressure. He's right about Harry: Harry *will* sacrifice himself to save his friends. But just in case Harry's inside the school, then Voldemort will attempt to use a tool he understands well: upping the fear quotient to trigger the betrayal of a friend, which might not only net him Harry Potter, but help to splinter the Resistance as well.
August 8th, 2007 at 10:56 am
I missed that explanation, Steve. Thanks!
Thanks for commenting, Ann-Marie. I can't help but think about the numerous times Voldemort had a chance to kill Harry but chose to waste time talking about how he was going to do it, giving Harry the chance to escape.
August 8th, 2007 at 12:55 pm
I can't help but think about the numerous times Voldemort had a chance to kill Harry but chose to waste time talking about how he was going to do it, giving Harry the chance to escape.
Villains are always overconfident, full of themselves. They think themselves in complete mastery of the situation. And sometimes they like to draw out these types of confrontations, savoring the moments just like a child is reluctant to take that last lick of the ice cream cone.
August 8th, 2007 at 2:23 pm
The reason the Cruciatus curse didn't harm Harry is because the Elder Wand won't turn on its master. That's why Harry was so confident that Voldemort wouldn't be able to kill him with it in Hogwarts. The only reason the Elder Wand was able to 'kill' Harry in the forest was because part of Voldemort's soul was in Harry. Voldemort, not being the master of the Elder Wand, was susceptible to the curse - so that 'part' of Harry died.
At least, that's what I gathered.
So does that mean Voldemort would not have been able to kill Dumbledore, because D fought V with the Elder Wand? And if the wand won't turn on its master, how does it get passed from wizard to wizard? - Admin
August 8th, 2007 at 2:26 pm
About Ron 'speaking' Parseltongue, it would be like me mimicking Spanish. Ron kind of explained himself when he told Harry that he thought he remembered from second year what Harry said - but it took him a few tries to get it right. The Chamber of Secrets simply had a password, and Ron guessed it - since it was in Parseltongue, not very many would be able to do so - and a non-speaker would only be able to guess if he/she heard it spoken before.
That's my take on it.
August 8th, 2007 at 8:17 pm
Merc–
I agree with you on that. It's called "transliteration." You're mimicking the sounds not the actual words–like singing a song in a foreign language without knowing what it means. The Chamber would just respond to the code sounds.
But Ron wasn't just remembering from second year. He also had heard those sounds when Harry opened the locket Horcrux. That was a very emotional moment for him, and would probably stick in his memory.
August 9th, 2007 at 3:05 am
Admin -
Voldemort was using the Elder Wand against its master - it wouldn't let him win. When Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald, he did so with his own wand against Grindelwald using the Elder Wand. The Elder Wand won't turn on its master. That doesn't mean an opponent can't beat the wielder of the Elder Wand with a different wand.
August 9th, 2007 at 3:07 am
Trish -
Ah, yes. I'd forgotten that Harry used Parseltongue to open the locket horcrux. It'd be much easier for Ron to remember that than to remember all the way back to second year.
August 9th, 2007 at 3:13 am
Also, I thought it was very appropriate that the battle scenes flew so quickly. War is chaos and speed. As fast as real modern warfare is, I can only imagine how fast magical warfare would be. Battles don't take days anymore. Many take a handful of hours. I think it would have felt contrived and artificial if Rowling walked us through all the casualties, explosions, duels and events of the battle. We saw the important stuff and felt as real observers would feel afterwards - that we just saw a hurricane go by and are quite sure we have no clue about the majority of what just happened.
August 9th, 2007 at 10:16 pm
The piece of Voldemort's soul that Harry witnessed in King's Cross wasn't the one that was in Harry. That one was dead. What he witnesses was the bit still alive in Voldemort. That was the only piece left besides the piece in Nagini, and it was the piece his blood was still attached to. Two things argue for this interpretation. One is that Harry wakes up from this experience to find that Voldemort was also unconscious during the experience. It's as if they were both in the waiting room until Harry decided to return. The other piece of evidence is Rowling's own statement since the book was published that Voldemort after death would not become a ghost but would have an existence like what Harry witnessed he would have in King's Cross of the deformed soul fragment. So she's clearly referring to that creature as what remains of Voldemort himself and not of any soul fragment from any Horcrux (including Harry the Horcrux).
Voldemort was really disturbed that nothing was working against Harry. He really wanted to hear how Harry kept doing the impossible. So of course he was going to listen to him. He may also have wanted information that would have prevented him from making another mistake now that he had Harry in front of him. Of course, when Harry told him the truth he didn't believe him and acted against Harry's words anyway. Very reminiscent of the later kings of Judah as Jeremiah kept warning them over and over, and they immediately went and did what the prophet had said would lead to their end.
August 12th, 2007 at 10:57 am
LaShawn, I had a very similar expectation as to Snape's end, and reaction to the way Snape died. And I still would personally rather it had been something like you thought, or something that allowed Snape and Harry to square things one on one.
But my first rejoinder to our expectation is — then it would have been my tale, not Rowling's, eh? (And quick review-question: which one of us has sold fifty-eight kajillion books?)
My second is: understatement and subtlety can often evoke more effectively than the opposite. No doubt there are places for (say) an actor to depict a character blubbering and carrying on; at other times, his suggestion of the inner turmoil creates that response in the audience. It fires the imagination, which is more powerful than the best novelist.
So it would indeed have been more satisfying for Snape and Harry to clear the air and get things right face to face. But on the other hand, we're slapped in the face with the abruptness of Snape's death, as Rowling (once again) twits all our expectations. Then the very subtle (i.e. I missed it) "Look at me." Then we're gripped with pathos as Harry sees — too late! — the meaning that framed his relationship with Snape.
And then the crowning touch: "Albus Severus."
Understatement => poignant evocation.
One Dan's opinion, your mileage may vary.
August 12th, 2007 at 1:32 pm
About Ron's imitation of Parseltongue - this is another example of something that's been set up since forever. We've actually been getting references to Ron's ability to imitate people/do impressions all through the series. It's just something that flew under most people's radar (if not everyone's).
I hated Snape's death at first, too, but I eventually decided that it was appropriate. Snape is a tragic figure and it's only appropriate that he gets a horribly tragic death, rather than going out in a blaze of glory as I had hoped.
(I actually wanted the Final Battle to take place in the Love Room in the Department of Mysteries. Snape would survive, and in the hubbub after Voldemort's death, Harry would slip off to the Death Room, and stand there staring at the Veil, remembering that "to the well-organized mind, death is but the last great adventure." Then Snape would show up, offer a few well-placed insults regarding Gryffindor courage, and then, having reminded Harry how much he has to live for, he would step beyond the Veil himself to face his own last great adventure. Glorious, noble, redeemed. It would be teh awesome. And totally untrue to the real canon character, though it would fit well with "fanon" Snape.)
August 13th, 2007 at 10:45 am
I have a problem with naming Harry's son "Albus Severus." It is an awful name. Just a little too much.
August 13th, 2007 at 8:18 pm
You know, Snape's death really had to be the way it was. That's the way spies die–"unwept, unhonored, and unsung". And Harry would never have listened to his story when he was alive. Dumbledore's murderer? No way! Snape is my favorite character, or one of them, but I don't think it could have happened any other way. And Harry had to learn about his own required death starkly, I think. He had to be shocked into the choice for it to be a real choice. IMO.
I don't think it's unrealistic that Voldemort gave the others an hour to turn Harry in. If anything it's too short. Five minutes, no minutes–people will say no once, and that's the end. Give them a longer time, and doubts will begin to set in. Maybe it would be better to sacrifice one person for the good of everyone. . . It's second thoughts that destroy. Voldemort knew that full well. It was the one thing he understood about people.
Stella!–I think Albus Severus is a fine name. Much better than Scorpius or Regulus Arcturus, anyway.
August 15th, 2007 at 4:03 pm
"That's the way spies die–"unwept, unhonored, and unsung".
I thought the sudden, off-hand execution of Snape was totally in Voldemort's character. The only deaths that he thinks about for more than a few seconds are his own, and Harry's. He's a psychopath - he sees others as things.
The Prince's Tale was well done. It was cinematic and the episodic nature made it even more hard hitting.
August 19th, 2007 at 12:17 am
Steve said:
I think the reason was explained by Harry in his info-dump to Voldemort right at the end. He told Voldemort that since the Elder Wand didn't belong to him, it wasn't working right (or something like that).
Looks correct Steve but if we see carefully, the wand that Voldemort was using was not the Elder wand at all. Harry has the Elder wand which he got from Draco.
August 19th, 2007 at 6:49 pm
Mean–
Harry did not get the Elder Wand from Draco. Draco never laid a hand on it. It fell from the Tower when Dumbledore was disarmed, and was entombed with him. Voldemort broke into the tomb to get it. The wand he was using was, indeed, the Elder Wand.
Draco became its true owner by defeating its then true owner, Dumbledore. He did not have to touch it, only to defeat the owner. Similarly, Harry became the true owner of the wand by disarming Draco, even though the wand itself was not in his physical possession at the time.